Business
Report Inaccuracy

Google Won’t Take Down a Review? What Ottawa Business Owners Should Do Next

Google Won’t Take Down a Review? What Ottawa Business Owners Should Do Next

Your review isn’t being taken down. What can you as a business owner in Ottawa do?

As a business owner in Ottawa, you’ve seen the review and lodged a complaint. However, upon checking, the review is still visible. You’ll receive an email from Google saying the review didn’t break any policies. This can be frustrating, particularly when you own a café in Hintonburg, garage in Orléans or a salon in Kanata and you feel the review is clearly wrong.

Knowing what steps to take next is key. Google has a strict process in place for assessing reported content, plus you can appeal once if eligible. As a business owner you can ensure you’re protecting your reputation during the process.

Understand why the review was not removed.

Google doesn’t remove any reviews based purely on how harsh, embarrassing or controversial they are. Their policies are focused on reviews that break their guidelines. Real customers will often have the freedom to leave a negative review about their experience.

This can be a big shock for many business owners. A 1-star rating without any comments isn’t automatically fake, nor is a review with an unknown display name. They could have made a booking under a different name, had a friend with them or a staff member.

Check if it breaks any policies.

Look through the content and see if it goes against any of Google’s guidelines. Most clear cases will be that there is clear evidence of the review being linked to a prohibited activity.

Possible cases are:

  • Fake engagement – Evidence that the reviewer didn’t actually experience anything, or multiple accounts were used to influence the rating.
  • Conflict of interest – Clear evidence that the reviewer is connected to your competitor or a professional relationship (current or past).
  • Irrelevant content – The post is mostly irrelevant to the business.
  • Threatening or personal information – Threats, targeted abuse or personal information.

These are listed on Google’s site. Simply stating that a staff member was named, or a complaint was made angrily or a short review wasn’t enough to show a review went against any policies. A good report should clearly highlight why the review may go against the policies, stating the specific words or actions.

Step 1: Check the status of the original report.

From your Google account, go to the Business Profile account that is affected. Go to Google’s guide to using the Reviews Management Tool. This will show you how to check the status of the review. Don’t assume that because it hasn’t been removed it has been rejected.

  • Decision pending – Google hasn’t completed their evaluation of the report.
  • Report reviewed – No policy breach – Google has decided not to remove the review, however there is a one-off appeal option.
  • Escalated – Check your email. Your appeal has been escalated.

Store this information in a simple folder or spreadsheet. Store the link to the review, when it was reported and the outcome. This will help prevent confusion if multiple people are helping you manage the account.

Step 2: Evidence

Imagine you run a repair shop in Ottawa and receive a review stating you did work on a vehicle you couldn’t identify. Whilst it may seem obvious that this is a fake review, it is best to firstly check your appointment book, invoices, alternative contact names and relevant dates.

Evidence can also help if the issue is due to a past employee, irrelevant issue or repetitive wording. Save any relevant public pages and information that you can legally access. Never include any private information from your customers in public replies.

A small bundle of evidence is often easiest to understand.

  • Link to review, date, star rating and full content.
  • Screenshot showing the review on the correct listing.
  • Category of policy breach.
  • 2-3 pieces of evidence, including dates or documents if possible.
  • A brief explanation of how this connects to the policy.

If you want to organise your facts before submitting your report, there’s a great blog on ReviewsBoost.ca blog explaining what to include. Ensure you’re only including facts that your business can prove.

Step 3: Appeal once.

If the review has been marked as eligible to appeal in the Reviews Management Tool, you can appeal. Go to the business, click ‘Check Previously Reported Reviews’ and select the eligible review. Complete the appeal form. At the moment, Google’s instructions state you can select up to 10 reviews.

Use this as an opportunity to clarify why the review shouldn’t be there. Add which policy it breaches, what part of the review and why you have evidence to back it up. If possible, keep it brief and don’t include any documents that include unnecessary personal information.

For example: “This post appears to concern a different business location. The review identifies a street address and service we do not operate. Please reassess whether the contribution accurately represents an experience with this Business Profile.” This would only make sense if you had evidence to back up your statement.

What if Google rejects your appeal?

Just because the review has been rejected again, doesn’t mean it’s true. It just means they couldn’t find any evidence to remove it using the relevant process. If there is no new avenue to take, re-reporting with the same unsupported statement probably won’t help.

Respond professionally to the review.

Many businesses in Ottawa will want to control what they can in the public eye. Keep it brief, polite and don’t include any information about your customers. Often people will look for evidence that someone from your business is listening. Particularly if the review doesn’t give much context.

“We take concerns like this seriously, but we have not been able to match the details to an interaction in our records. Please contact our team directly with the date and location so we can look into it privately.”

Tailor this to your situation. If the customer genuinely had a bad experience, acknowledge the issue and offer a solution. Don’t offer any discounts or gifts in return for editing/deleting the review. Google forbids you from offering incentives for reviews.

Encourage genuine feedback.

Continue to encourage real customers to leave honest feedback. Don’t filter for positive reviews or suggest you want a certain star rating. Having a consistent flow of genuine feedback will give people a wider insight into your business and create a healthier history of customer experiences.

Can a review removal agency help?

If you’ve already received a rejection from Google as a business owner in Ottawa, you may want a second opinion. A review removal agency can help you understand if the content does go against any Google policies, organise any relevant documents and tell you what options you have to report the review. However they cannot override Google’s decision or make a normal negative opinion into a policy breach.

2 Agencies that offer review removal in Canada.

ReviewRemoval.ca can help Canadian businesses dispute controversial Google reviews. Ask them to explain what policy they believe the review breaches, what evidence they would need and what they would do if the initial report wasn’t successful.

ReviewsBoost.ca can also help Canadian businesses with managed Google review removal. Their website has some great informative resources. You can request an evaluation. Compare how they operate, communicate and charge to others to decide if you want to use an external agency.

Ask for the terms of the service, including any upfront costs, costs after removal and how they know it was successful. If Google has already rejected your appeal, ask what legitimate options you have next. Be cautious of any that promise guaranteed removal or special influence over the moderation team.

No external agencies can force Google to remove the review. If the post contains threatening, extortionate or potentially defamatory statements you may also want to seek advice from a qualified legal professional.

A realistic approach for neighbourhood businesses in Ottawa.

Businesses in Ottawa serve very different communities, from shops in the city centre, restaurants in the ByWard Market and independent service businesses in Barrhaven and Nepean. Whilst there are different pressures to deal with, the main thing to consider when deciding to dispute a review is whether you can identify a real policy breach and back it up with facts.

Local business owners are making some big decisions about their future as explained in a recent feature in the Ottawa Times. Ensuring you have a trustworthy reputation in the public eye should be considered. Check the status, appeal if eligible, respond professionally and continue to provide great service to your customers.

Share: Facebook X