Business
Report Inaccuracy

Why Ottawa businesses get buried in Google Maps (even with a decent website), and what actually fixes it

Why Ottawa businesses get buried in Google Maps (even with a decent website), and what actually fixes it

Picture this. It’s a Saturday morning in Barrhaven and a pipe under the kitchen sink has started leaking. You grab your phone and type “plumber near me.” Three businesses pop up on the map. None of them is the family-run shop two streets over that your neighbours swear by, the one with the nice website and twenty years in the area.

I see this all the time. Good Ottawa businesses with solid reputations, invisible on the map. Usually it isn’t because they’re doing a bad job. It’s because Google doesn’t have enough to go on.

How Google Maps decides who shows up

Google says local results come down to three things: relevance, distance and prominence.

Relevance is how well your listing matches what someone searched. Distance is how close you are to the person searching, or to the area they typed in. Prominence is how well known and trusted you seem, based on things like reviews, mentions around the web and your website.

You can’t move your shop closer to every customer, so relevance and prominence are where the work is. And here’s the part that surprises a lot of owners: for the map, your Google Business Profile usually matters more than your website. The website helps. But the profile is what Google reads first.

The five most common reasons Ottawa businesses get buried

1. The profile is incomplete or wrong. The primary category is the big one. A physio clinic in Kanata listed as “Medical clinic” instead of “Physiotherapist” is fighting with one hand tied behind its back. Missing services, old hours and no photos don’t help either.

2. Reviews are thin, old or ignored. If your newest review is from 2022 and you never replied to any of them, the business down the road with steady, recent reviews will usually win. Replies matter more than people think. They show Google, and customers, that someone’s home.

3. Your name, address and phone number don’t match everywhere.

 Yelp says one suite number, YellowPages has your old phone line, and the BBB listing still shows the location you left in Nepean three years ago. Each mismatch makes Google a little less sure about you.

4. There are no real pages for the areas you serve. If you work in Orléans, Westboro and Gatineau, your website should say so, with a page for each that’s actually useful. Copying one page and swapping the neighbourhood name doesn’t count, and Google can tell.

5. The profile looks abandoned. No posts, unanswered questions, no new photos since opening day. A profile that never changes looks like a business that might not be open.

What I see with clients

I’m not going to put words in anyone’s mouth, but the patterns are pretty consistent. Most owners who come to us have tried something. They paid for a new website and expected the map to follow. They asked for reviews in one big push, then stopped. Or someone set up the profile years ago, and nobody has logged in since.

None of that is wasted effort. It just doesn’t stick on its own. What moves the needle is boring, steady work done every week.

A simple weekly routine

You don’t need an agency to do most of this. You need about half an hour a week and a bit of discipline.

  • Ask for a review after every job or visit. A short text with a direct link works better than a sign at the till.
  • Reply to every review, good or bad. Keep it short, thank them, and fix what you can.
  • Add two or three new photos a week: your team, your work, your storefront in every season.
  • Post one update a week on your profile, like a seasonal offer, a finished project or a tip.
  • Check your hours before every holiday. Ottawa has plenty of them, and “open” on Family Day when you’re closed annoys people fast.
  • Keep your name, address and phone number exactly the same on your website, your profile and every directory you’re listed in.

That’s it. It’s not glamorous, but it’s the stuff that actually changes where you show up.

The new wrinkle: AI search

More people are now asking Google’s AI answers or ChatGPT for recommendations, like “best dentist in Westboro.” Those tools lean on the same signals the map does: reviews, consistent listings and clear pages about what you do and where. So the work above isn’t just for Google Maps. It’s how you get mentioned in those answers, too.

Where to start this week

Open your Google Business Profile today and check one thing: your primary category. Make sure it describes your main service as precisely as Google allows. Then ask your last five happy customers for a review.

If you’d rather have help, that’s what we do at Profit Parrot. We’re an Ottawa SEO company that works with local businesses on exactly this. Either way, start with the category. It takes five minutes.

contributed by Lark Begin of Profit Parrot

About the author

Lark Begin is the founder of Profit Parrot, an Ottawa SEO and digital marketing agency that helps local businesses get found on Google Maps, in search and in AI answers. She works with home service companies, clinics and retailers across Ottawa and beyond.

Share: Facebook X